By Book or By Crook by Eva Gates is the first in the Lighthouse Library series. This is a fabulous beginning to this series for any book lover or cozy mystery enthusiast. Lucy is very excited to be hired as the new librarian for the Outer Banks and is hoping it is exactly the escape from Boston she needs. However, her new job is off to a rocky beginning when the chair of the library board is found murdered and a priceless Jane Austen novel has gone missing. Now Lucy is finding herself right in the middle of the investigation.
The setting of Bodie Island and the lighthouse is wonderful. You can visualize how beautiful the inside of the lighthouse must be. I also enjoyed all of the characters. Lucy is smart and doesn’t do the typical, “I know I shouldn’t go in there” routine that occasionally happens in cozy mysteries. I am excited to see how the characters progress. All of the them have potential to really develop and grow as we continue our library journey. The books in this mystery are amazing. I loved how the entire community embraces the Austen collection and becomes fans. This is a fun and cute series to start if you are looking for something that isn’t a cooking or knitting cozy. Although I think fiction fans might enjoy this story. It is very much a character driven tale.